4 Best and 4 Worst Diaper Pails For Your Nursery


Excellent diaper pails that are diaper genie alternatives so you can worry less about purchasing odor-controlling refills and extra bags, and focus on enjoying your new bundle of joy.

(This post contains affiliate links. Our full disclosure policy is really boring, but you can find it here.)

Awesome Diaper Pales That Are Great Diaper Genie Alternatives

The Diaper Genie by Playtex is the number one best-selling diaper pails due to its “Odour Lock System” that features a built-in, odor-controlling double airtight clamp system to help seal the doors.

On top of that, there is a carbon filter at the very top of the pail to eliminate any other odors to try to escape the diaper pail.

Stink control is a big problem when it comes to diaper pails which is why the Diaper Genie is so popular.

Another handy feature of the Diaper genie is the foot pedal which prevents the need to bend down and open the pail to throw in your dirty diaper.

While the Diaper Genie is really an all-in-one system for managing dirty diapers, some parents may be on the hunt for something with different functions, perhaps something that doesn’t require extra special disposal bags and odor control refills.

Luckily, there are many options available for new parents to choose from and we have put together a comprehensive list of the best alternatives to the diaper genie from affordability to alternate features you might be looking for in a diaper bin.

Best Diaper Pails and Bins

Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail

4.2/5 Star Review

The Dekor Plus Hands Free Diaper Pail is as close to the Diaper Genie as you can get, and it is certainly an acceptable alternative.

This pail comes in 3 sizes, the Mini, Classic, and Plus which can hold 25, 45, and 60 dirty diapers, depending on the diaper sizes you are using.

If your nursery is a smaller size, the mini may be a better option for you as it takes up less room.

Once your baby is finished with diapers, you can convert the Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail into a regular trash can by removing the diaper trap door.

This diaper pail also comes in pink, grey, white and blue to perfectly match your nursery.

The smell isn’t an issue with this pail system as the Dekor pail features an odor control system to keep odors at bay.

3 Different SizesRequires Special Bags
Variety Of Colors
Foot Pedal For Hands-Free Use

Odorless Cloth Diaper Pail

The Odorless Cloth Diaper Pail is designed for cloth diapers, but you can use it for disposable diapers too.

This is a great pail that is simple to use and care for.

This is a plastic bucket, with a plastic lid, but it also has a charcoal filter on the lid for odor control.

The locking lid is very helpful if you have pets or other children who like to get up to mischief.

You can use a large trash bag with this pail and hold a lot of dirty diapers in it.

The plastic is actually recycled and is built to lock in odors. This is a good option for cloth diapers, disposable diapers, and wet diapers too.

Because of the capacity of this pail, you can easily toss diapers for days for twins before needing to change the trash bag out.

Yes, it is a large plastic bucket with a lid, so it seems pricey for the design.

Made with recycled plasticIs a large plastic trash can
Has charcoal disk for odour control
Locking lid
Can use any regular trash bag
Can be used for cloth diapers and disposables
Great for twins

Ubbi Odor Locking Diaper Pail

4.3/5 Star Review

The Ubbi Odor Locking Diaper Pail is a nice alternative to the Diaper Genie as it does have odor locking technology and an easy slide open top to drop in dirty diapers.

There is no foot pedal to this pail which does make it less desirable to some parents but it is easy to slide open at the top of the pail and does have a child safety lock so children do not put their toys in the pail.

You can use any diaper pail bag refills with this pail but it is recommended that you use the Ubbi Disposable Bags.

Child Lock LidNo Foot Pedal
Variety Of Colors
Can Use Any Diaper Pail Refill Bags

Munchkin Step Diaper Pail

The Munchkin Step Diaper Pail is a gold standard diaper pail that has odor control and a sleek design with an easy-to-use foot pedal.

This is a really great diaper pail for parents. It is affordable and it keeps the smell away. You can purchase scented liners as well – we love the lavender.

There is a baking soda wheel that helps keep the smell away and the whole system is very easy to use.

Refill bags simply snap close when it’s time to change the bag out so the smell stays within the liner as you transport it to the outside bin.

This system can hold up to 30 diapers, depending on diaper size, which is a little bit more than other diaper pail systems can hold.

The design of this system is easy to use and easy to clean as well. It works well with most nursery themes and has a sleek look to it.

The one thing we don’t love about this diaper is the fact that you have to use a little force to push the diaper into the pail. If the diaper is rather full, it can be a yucky experience. We do wish the opening was larger, but also that would mean the smell is more likely to come through. You win some, you lose some.

Because you have to purchase special liners for this bin, you must add that to your monthly baby budget. Every few months you will also want to change out the baking soda disk.

We do recommend changing the liners often, especially if the diapers are particularly stinky once the baby starts eating solid foods. The nursery will begin to smell if the liners are not changed out often enough.

Awarded 2020 Best Overall Diaper Pail by the Good Housekeeping InstituteNeeds special liners
Patented self-sealing system 
For every Step Diaper Pail sold, Munchkin will plant a tree
Measures 27” high x 12” deep
Comes with a step pedal to open hands-free
Childproof locking system
Durable plastic pail

Diaper Systems That Don’t Eliminate Odours As Well

Playtex Diaper Genie

The original diaper genie was amazing, but the Playtex Diaper Genie Complete isn’t as great, unfortunately.

While the origi0onal diaper genie did lock in odors well, many customers complain that the new model does not.

This tall pail requires no bending with a foot pedal for easy, hygienic, and hands-free opening which is nice.

The Complete Pail features Double Air-Tite Clamps that work with the 7-layer diaper pail refill bags and carbon filter to add a layer of double dooty odor protection, which unfortunately doesn’t work as well as it is designed to.

Over 1.5 million moms put their trust in Diaper Genie Complete for a fresher-smelling nursery.

Built-In Odor Controlling AntimicrobialRequires diaper genie refill bags
Carbon filterDoes not lock in odours well
Clean laundry scent

Tommee Tippee Simplee Diaper Pail

4.4/5 Star Review

There is no denying that Tommee Tippee is a trusted baby brand. We did expect a little more from the Tommee Tippee Simplee diaper pail.

The pail features an odour locking antibacterial agent that kills germs.

This pail has a smart lid which you flip open, pop the diaper in and it flip it back down.

The biggest issue with this diaper pail is the location of the trap door. You have to place your entire hand into the diaper pail while holding the baby on the changing table to prevent her from rolling off. Kind of a tricky design!

This easy-to-use and compact diaper pail can hold up to 18 diapers, which is not as bad as it sounds because you take the diapers out to the outside bin more often, meaning less chance of getting a stinky nursery.

Kills germsholds 18 diapers
Small and compactDoesn’t lock in odors well
Have to stick entire arm inside diaper pail to place diaper in

Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail

4.2/5 Star Review

At a comfortable price point, the Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail is a parent favorite, but it doesn’t lock in odors quite as well as other diaper pails.

One nice feature is that you can use any plastic bag inside this pail which means you don’t have to spend extra cash on special refills.

This pail does not feature a step pedal which kind of sucks. The access to the bin is at the top of the lid where you press the button and the top pops open to throw in your dirty diapers.

There is a deodorizer disk to help keep odours at bay, and you can purchase refills of these if you need them.

The problem with this diaper pail is that while they certainly tried to make a pail that traps smell, they failed to ensure that the smell actually stays in the pail. You can smell the diapers from a whole different room!

Overall this is a simple and affordable diaper system, just know that you’ll have to be extra diligent in changing out the bags to try to control the smell.

Can hold up to 50 diapersDoesn’t fit larger diapers in
Can use any regular bagNo foot pedal
Has deodorizer diskDoes not lock in odours well
Taller Base and ergonomic lid

Bubula Steel Diaper Pail

We wish we could love the Bubula Steel Diaper Pail. It is the only other steel pail like the Ubbi, but it doesn’t work as well and fails to meet the needs of many consumers.

The pail is made with steel all over except for the hinges. This is where people report the lid breaks off often.

Unfortunately many reports that this pail doesn’t lock in odors. A diaper pail’s main job is to make sure the nursery stays stink-free, and this one fails at the job.

Unfortunately, a lot of customers also reported that the product needs to be replaced after a few months of use. Any diaper pail worth investing in should last a couple of years, which makes this a very disappointing product overall.

It does have some good things, such as the easy-to-operate design, and it comes in many different colors to match any nursery as well.

Even though the product tends to fail often, the customer service for this pail is great. You will get your pail replaced if it malfunctions without question. It’s not a terrible choice for a diaper pail, but there are some better options out there for steel diaper pails, such as the Ubbi.

Steel and aluminum construction with air-tight lid to prevents odorsMany customers reported the lid snapping and breaking
Taller base and ergonomic lid designDoesn’t hold in smells well
Includes safety lockExpensive
Unique design easily converts to a regular trash can for long-term use in any room
Uses standard-size can liners

Guide To Buying A Diaper Pail

Do you need a diaper pail for your home? Yes and no. If you are ok with throwing dirty diapers into your regular trash can after each change, and keeping up with the trash being taken to the outside garbage on a regular basis, then sure, you may not need a diaper pail.

However, if you are busy, and need somewhere quick to throw a dirty diaper where the dog won’t eat it and the room won’t start to smell, then a diaper pail is a good idea.

Diaper Pail Must-Have Features

Control smell: Diapers get stinky. Not so much in the newborn stages, but when the baby starts eating solid foods around 4-6 months of age, the diapers get downright yucky. Babies use up to 12 diapers a day, and that adds up super quick and gets really smelly in a small room like a nursery. A diaper pail can help eliminate odours by locking up the dirty diapers and masking the smells. Some diaper pails use baking soda, activated charcoal or scented garbage bags as a secondary measure for masking the smells. It gets pretty bad sometimes, and a diaper pail can help you from having to ensure foul smells. Some diapers twist individual bags so the diapers are trapped inside their very own little baggie, making it darn near impossible to smell that sucker.

Easy to empty and reload: You’ll be changing the diaper pail liners out every two days or so. A good diaper pail will be easy to load and reload. Some diaper pails require you to tie a bag inside of the pail shell, which can be a bit of a pain in the butt when you’re busy with a new baby.

Easy disposal: A diaper pail should be easy to remove the diaper bag from and the bag should contain the smell of the diapers while you walk through the house to the outside bin. Diapers should not fall out and the bag should not rip. Some liners are very thin and can rip if there are too many diapers in them and others can rip due to the design of the diaper pail. Diaper pail should be easy to use and should have high-quality bags.

Price Point: With so many other nursery requirements, a diaper pail shouldn’t cost an arm and a leg. For a higher quality pail, you will pay more money, and you may even have to spend monthly on liners as well. These are all things to consider when looking for a diaper pail.

Size and style: This is an item that is going into your nursery so you don’t want to purchase something that is going to be an eyesore. You’ll likely want a pail that can hold more than 14 diapers at a time so you don’t have to change it every second day.

Tips for Choosing The Best Diaper Pail

There are a few must haves when it comes to a diaper pail and most diaper pails do have these features built in, but the alternatives may not so you’re going to want to look for these features in your home made diaper pail.

  • Must have a lid
  • Step pedal is a bonus
  • The material of bin can be disinfected
  • Do not purchase a diaper pail you plan on using for regular garbage as well as diapers
  • Stainless steel is a great option that doesn’t lock in odours like plastic

Frequently Asked Questions About Diaper Pails

How To Prevent Diaper Pails From Stinking

Sometimes the stench of the diaper pail is enough to make anyone feel nauseous, and that smell will stick to your baby too, so it’s a great idea to have some odor repelling tactics in your knowledge base to prevent some of these stinks from happening.

Some natural ways you can eliminate diaper pail odors:

  1. Add a coffee filter at the bottom of the diaper pail to absorb the stink
  2. No coffee filter? Try a dryer sheet instead
  3. Spray white vinegar into the pail every time you empty it. Vinegar is a natural odor eliminator.
  4. Sprinkle some baking soda at the bottom of the diaper pail. You can refresh the baking soda each time you take out the bag.
  5. Add cloves to the bottom of the bin, the strong smell of clove will cover up any diaper stink you may smell.
  6. Old coffee grounds are also excellent odor absorbents, dump some in a plastic container, and place at the bottom of the pail.
  7. You can use a scooped out lemon half filled with salt and place it at the bottom of the pail and replace it every week before it gets moldy.
  8. Wash out the diaper pail after removing the bag of dirty diapers.

Remember that dirty diaper pails are a health hazard and should never get to the point where the stench is unbearable.

Mold can grow on diapers from moisture in the air combined with the feces in the diaper, which is not healthy to have floating around your nursery.

Keep your nursery safe by changing your diaper bags often and before they get really smelly.

Diaper Disposal Safety

Your new baby is going to go through a lot of diapers, so it is a good idea to know how to dispose of them properly.

Disposable diapers have the potential to be a health hazard to the public and there is something to consider when throwing them away whether you are at home or out in public.

Cloth diapering has certainly become rather popular once again, but disposable diapers are still an option that many families use.

Disposable diapers are so easy to use, we certainly see the appeal of them at baby gadget list, but throwing away plastic wrapped feces into the trash can pose some health risks.

It is recommended that all feces should be dumped into the toilet, even if you are using disposable diapers.

These are just a few of the bacteria that can be found in feces.

  • Gastrointestinal viruses.
  • Hepatitis.
  • E. coli.
  • Salmonella.
  • Norovirus.
  • Polio.

These are all very dangerous, and proper diaper disposal is very much necessary.

How To Dispose Of Diapers Properly

  1. Throw all feces into the toilet before disposing of diapers.
  2. Wrap the diaper up in within itself (so it’s a ball) and secure with the straps
  3. Place diaper into diaper pail or plastic bag and seal it up
  4. Dispose of the diaper in an outdoor garbage bin
  5. Wash your hands

The Best Diaper Bins For The Nursery

While the Diaper Genie certainly is very popular, it is not the only odour controlling pail you can purchase for your beautiful nursery. Having options for diaper pails that do not require special maintenance such as extra bags or odour elimination products can help new parents save money on their baby essentials.

My favourite diaper bin is the Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail specifically because it is well designed, has an excellent and affordable price point and parents love how easy it is to use. It also helps keep the nursery from smelling, especially if you take proper precautions and empty the pail on a regular basis.

More Like this

Diaper Genie Alternatives

Similar Posts