How To Decide What Kind Of Crib Mattress To Buy – Foam or Coil


Is it better to have a foam or coil crib mattress for your baby?
If you’re deciding between a foam or coil baby mattress, keep in mind that each has advantages and disadvantages.

Foam crib mattresses are less expensive and lighter. This is beneficial due to the necessity for regular bedding changes with newborns. The chemicals and VOC off-gassing of some polyurethane foam mattresses are disadvantages of purchasing a foam baby mattress. Because flame retardants are a major problem, you should look into the company’s policies and see if they use flame retardant chemicals. Add in the environmental effect, poor temperature regulation, low durability, lack of waterproofing, and the possibility for indentation, and you have a recipe for disaster.

When compared to foam baby mattresses, coil crib mattresses provide a lot of advantages. Greater weight distribution, better edge support, longer-lasting and more durable, improved waterproofing and water-resistance, and better temperature management for newborns are just a few of these benefits. In general, coils produce a more breathable baby mattress.

An innerspring mattress has the disadvantage of being more costly and heavier. If the cover rips or shreds, springs and coils may be exposed to the infant.

If you’re debating whether to choose a foam or coil crib mattress, keep reading to find out which is best for you.

How To Decide What Kind Of Crib Mattress To Buy – Foam or Coil

It’s all about comfort when buying a mattress for an adult. When it comes to buying a mattress for a newborn, though, safety is parnumber.

Experts believe that providing a secure sleeping environment is one of the most effective ways to reduce the risk of SUDI and SIDS. Choosing a firm crib mattress that fits properly in the crib, placing your baby to sleep on his or her back, and remembering that “bare is best” are all important considerations.

That sounds wonderful in principle, but what happens when it’s time to buy a newborn crib mattress? There are a lot of choices out there, and one of the first decisions you’ll have to make is whether to choose a foam or coil baby mattress.

Both have advantages and disadvantages that are obvious.

Foam Mattress

Polyurethane is used to make foam mattresses. While you should avoid memory foam for a crib mattress due to safety concerns, there are plenty of conventional foam baby mattresses that are certified safe by authorities – even if they do contain some potentially hazardous chemicals.

In general, you should get a foam crib mattress that is made particularly for a crib. To be safe, crib mattresses must be firm, and ordinary foam mattresses may be too soft.

The cost and lightness of a foam mattress are two advantages.

The chemical odour and off-gassing of conventional foam mattresses (and the chemicals in most foam mattresses), the environmental impact of conventional foam, poor temperature regulation compared to innerspring coil crib mattresses, durability and lack of waterproofing, and the potential to indent, posing a hazard to your baby are all disadvantages of choosing a foam crib mattress.

The construction of a foam mattress is not as complicated as that of a coil mattress. It has, however, been shown to be as efficient in providing your baby with firmness and appropriate support.

A polyurethane foam core is wrapped by a vinyl or cloth cover in foam crib mattresses.

A dual-sided foam crib mattress, which has two layers of varying hardness, is another option. One side is comprised of a firmer foam that provides a safe resting environment for infants and little children. The opposite side, for toddlers, features plushier memory foam for added comfort.

Fabric coverings, on the other hand, are generally just water-resistant but more breathable than vinyl covers. In any case, the best coverings include many layers, double or triple laminated ticking, and nylon reinforcement. These coverings are more robust, less prone to rips and holes, and can withstand more frequent washing.

Foam mattresses come in a variety of thicknesses, with most models falling between 3 and 6 inches thick. Foam crib mattresses are also light in weight. The majority of them weigh less than 13 pounds. Because of these qualities, replacing sheets on innerspring models is typically easier.

The foam in superior foam mattresses is denser and of higher quality. These versions are a little heavier than innerspring crib mattresses, but they’re still a little lighter.

Coil Mattress

Coil and innerspring mattresses are constructed out of a variety of materials, including metal coils that support and firm the mattress, as well as interior materials such as foam or latex. The mattress cover is constructed of a sturdy polyester or cotton blend, and it may or may not be water-proof or water-resistant.

In an innerspring crib mattress, the mattress coils offer firmness and support. In general, crib mattresses have between 80 and 250 coils. In general, a mattress with a larger coil count has a more consistent firmness over the surface and is less prone to have peaks and valleys, or soft regions. 

While the number of coils has an impact on how even the firmness is across the mattress, the actual firmness is determined by a combination of two factors: the number of coils and the thickness (gauge) of the steel used to construct the coils.

When comparing apples to apples, the more coils, the firmer the mattress. It’s more difficult to discern which mattress will be firmer if you’re comparing mattresses made of various gauge steel.

When compared to foam baby mattresses, innerspring coil crib mattresses provide a lot of advantages. Greater weight distribution, better edge support, longer-lasting and durable, higher waterproofing and water-resistance, better temperature control for infants, and more breathability are just a few of the benefits.

An innerspring mattress has the disadvantage of being more costly and heavier. If the cover rips or shreds, springs and coils may be exposed to the infant.

Because of the springs in their core, innerspring/coil baby mattresses are heavier. They weigh between 15 and 30 pounds.

The quantity and thickness of steel coils in the core determine the quality and firmness of innerspring crib mattresses. More coils in a crib mattress are typically preferable. When there are more springs in a given space, they are closer to one another, resulting in a more stable structure.

More coils, on the other hand, do not automatically imply more stiffness. You must discover the ideal coil count and steel gauge combination (coil thickness). A mattress with fewer coils but a thicker steel gauge is likely to be firmer than one with more inferior innerspring.

The insulated pad is the initial layer, and it keeps the coils from poking through the mattress’s top layer. Fiber wrap pads made from pressed pieces of fabric and coir fibre pads composed of crushed coconut shells are the finest insulator pads. Although coconut pads are more costly, they are both suitable for use in baby mattresses.

Woven polyester, firm felt, and plastic mesh insulator pads are examples of lower-quality insulator pads. Innerspring mattresses with such insulator pads are less resilient, have a tendency to form pockets and grow concave with time, posing a safety issue.

The cushioning layer sits on top of the insulated pad. Cotton, foam, or polyester can all be used.

While cotton and foam are acceptable options, avoid polyester. Yes, it is less expensive, making the entire purchase more reasonable, but polyester cushioning is less durable, and mattresses with polyester cushioning create pockets more quickly.

A cloth or vinyl cover surrounds the entire innerspring infant crib mattress. Fabric coverings allow for more airflow, while vinyl covers are more durable. A multilayer vinyl cover outperforms a fabric cover in terms of resistance to rips, punctures, stains, and leaks.

However, selecting vinyl over cloth does not necessitate sacrificing breathability. Look for a mattress with side venting holes, which allow for optimal air circulation.

Which Mattress Is Better For Your Baby?

As you can see from the information presented, both have advantages and disadvantages. The one you should select is completely depending on your expectations from the mattress. The coil is your best choice if you want something that will be utilized for a long time. Memory foam mattresses are ideal if you want something that feels more like your own bed and that your baby enjoys.

I mentioned a few nice mattress alternatives above, but if you want something that is both comfy and supportive, the Naturepedic is the way to go. It belongs to our organic category, and it has strong springs, superb edge support, and is dual-sided.

Similar Posts