The best Baby Pacifier

Best Non-toxic Pacifiers For Your Baby (BPA free)

The best non-toxic pacifier options available for your baby

(This post contains affiliate links. Our full disclosure policy is really boring, but you can find it here.)

Our Picks: The Best Non Toxic Pacifiers

There are so many options for pacifiers on the market today, it can be easy to get lost in what to purchase for your little bundle of joy.

We love the option of having a non-toxic pacifier for your little ones and we created this guide for you to make the selection process easier.

The quick notes are: rubber pacifiers are the best choice as they are made out of 100 percent rubber materials. These options are more on the expensive side, so we did include some more affordable options as well. All options listed here are non-toxic.

The Best Non-Toxic Pacifier For Baby

Philips Avent Soothie – $3.19USD

4.7/5 Star Review

This is a silicone one piece pacifer that is very popular with parents and is distributed in hospitals worldwide.

This BPA free dishwasher safe dummy is sized and shaped for babies mouth and is latex free.

Priced at $3.19 for a pack of 2, this is a great deal for a non toxic pacifier.

Dishwasher SafeWide Shield Can Be Heavy For Newborn (Better Suited For 3+ Months)
BPA Free
Latex Free

This is our number 1 recommendation as the best non-toxic pacifier due to the price point, shape of nipple and amazing reviews from parents on our team at Baby Gadget List and t hose on Amazon reviews.

Ryan and Rose Pacifier– $11.99 USD

4.7/5 Star Review

This is a great stage 1 pacifier for babies with no teeth.

This pacifier is made with 100% medical-grade silicone that’s BPA, PVC, latex, and phthalate-free.

The nipple mimics a mothers nipple which makes this a great option for breastfed babies.

Dishwasher SafeCannot Use Once Teeth Sprout
BPA, PVC, Latex, and Phthalate free

This is an awesome stage 1 non-toxic pacifier that has parents raving about how much babies love it.

HAVEA Star & Moon Pacifier – $9.00 USD

4.4/5 Star Review

This 100% rubber pacifier is a great option for newborns to 3 months of age.

This natural fit rubber pacifier is easy to clean by hand, and is softer than traditional pacifiers making it easy to such on for newborns.

Latex Free Will Melt In Sterilizer
Easy To Clean
Natural Fit

This is a great pacifier if you are ok with not using a sterilizer to wash it!

Chicco Silicone Pacifier – $5.99 USD

4.4/5 Star Review

This 100% silicone pacifier features a one piece design with easy hold handle.

The lateral curve of the nipple evenly distributes the tongue’s pressure against the palate and the tiny ridges and inclined nipple shape guide proper tongue placement.

BPA and LATEX FreeCollects Lint And Dust Easily
Narrow Base For Lip Closure
Supports Babies Breathing

The Chicco silicone pacifier is a good option for parents to love the one piece design. The price point on this pacifier is reasonable and affordable for most households.

Natursutten Natural Rubber Pacifier – $12.00 USD

4.1/5 Star Review

The Natursutten pacifier is made from the Hevea Brasiliensi tree in Malaysia.

The natural rubber is soft and the large shield touches the nose comfortable.

this one piece design is hygenic due the nature of the one piece not having any joints where dirt can get trapped.

100% Natural Rubber
One Piece Design
No BPA, nitrosamines, PVC, phthalates, chemical softeners, or artificial coloring.

The Natursutten pacifier is a great investment for environmentally conscious parents. This pacifier is made in Malaysia.

Ecopacifier Natural Rubber Pacifier– $9.99 USD

4.2/5 Star Review

The ecopacifer is a natural rubber pacifier that is plastic-free, bpa-free, pvc-free, paraben-free and uses no chemical-softeners or extra colorants.

This pacifier is softer and more natural than silicone pacifiers.

The one-piece design helps keep dirt and small particles from getting trapped in the pacifier.

This is a hand washable, not dishwasher safe pacifier due to it’s natural rubber material.

Made in Malaysia from a rubber tree, Hevea brasillensi.

100% Natural RubberHigher Priced
No BPA, nitrosamines, PVC, phthalates, chemical softeners, or artificial coloring.Not Dishwasher Safe

The ecopacifier is a great investment for environmentally conscious parents. This pacifier is made in Malaysia.

Guide To Buying A Non-Toxic Pacifier

How Does A Pacifier Comfort Baby?

Babies have a natural sucking action that they do while they are still in the womb. This motion is essential for babies’ survival, due to the nature of needing to eat from the mother’s nipple (or a bottle.)

Most pediatricians recommend that you don’t introduce a pacifier or dummy to your newborn until you have a set breastfeeding routine as this can prevent the disruption of your breastfeeding journey. This is due to the possibility of nipple confusion where the baby might prefer to suck on the pacifier instead of the nipple which can cause latching issues.

A pacifier can comfort a baby because the natural sucking action that happens lowers babies’ heart rate, blood pressure, and stress levels.

If your baby needs to go for vaccinations, or blood tests, a pacifier can help reduce crying after the procedures.

If your baby is feeding by bottle only, then you should be able to introduce a pacifier right away with no issues.

Are Pacifiers Good For Baby?

Baby pacifiers certainly have a bad rap, but are they actually good or bad for baby?

Well in 1879 a German pediatrician laid claim that pacifiers led to mouth deformities and immorality.

But that was a long time ago. How can a natural sucking motion that babies practice while in the womb be immoral actions?

The bottom line?

American Academy of Pediatrics says “Pacifiers do not cause any medical or psychological problems.” 

Pro’s And Con’s Of Using A Pacifier (Advantages and Disadvantages)

Can Soothe Fussy BabyCan Interfere With Breastfeeding
Distracts Baby Baby Can Become Dependant On Pacifier
Can Help Baby SleepMight Increase Risk Of Ear Infection
Can Help During FlightsProlonged Use Can Lead To Dental Issues
Can Help Reduce Risk Of SIDS

How to Choose The Best Pacifier For Your Baby

Your little one will likely have a pacifier preference, just like they can have a baby bottle preference.

Some styles can be more soothing for one baby than some other pacifier due to shape or material and texture.

Some babies are not picky at all. It can be difficult to buy a perfect pacifier for your baby before the baby is born, but there is no harm in having a few select styles for babies to choose from when they are ready for their pacifier.


Traditional pacifiers have 3 different parts: nipple, shield and ring. Newer style pacifiers are made from one piece of molded silicone or rubber materials.

Selecting a pacifier based on traditional parts or modern style will widely depend on parental preference.

Most pacifiers do have a hole where you can attach a pacifier strap to keep baby from losing her dummy.


You can buy a pacifier that matches your baby’s age. A pacifier that is too big or too small can cause discomfort and will do the opposite of soothing the baby.

Sizing Guide:

Small: Newborn to 6 months

Medium: 6-18 Months

Large: 18+ Months

It is a good idea to stick the age guidelines on the pacifier packaging to ensure the pacifier you are purchasing is right for your baby.


Most pacifier nipples are made from silicone, latex or rubber.

A silicone pacifier is usually dishwasher safe and will not retain odors.

A latex pacifier wears out faster than silicone, retains scent more often and has to be hand washed.

There are also special one-piece pacifiers that are made from sturdy rubber. These pacifiers tend to be more expensive than silicone or latex models, but a lot of babies do prefer the texture of the rubber material.

What Type Of Pacifier Is Best For Baby?

When choosing a pacifier you will want to consider your baby’s needs, likes, and dislikes. If you have a breastfed baby, you may want to try a few rubber natural nipple pacifiers such as the Ryan and Rose or the Natursutten pacifiers.

Ultimately, it will be up to the baby if they enjoy a pacifier or not.

Are Silicone or Latex Pacifiers Better?

Typically there are more reported allergies to latex and therefore we do recommend silicone over latex pacifiers.

Nipple Confusion And Pacifier

When a baby is newborn and is breastfeeding, they can get nipple confused, which is why pediatricians recommend avoiding pacifier use until an established breastfeeding routine is in place, around 1 month.

What is an Orthodontic Pacifier?

Most pacifiers on the market are Orthodontic. This just means that your baby’s top and bottom jaw are in the correct position when the pacifier is being used which helps prevent issues with jaw growth.

The Do’s and Don’ts of pacifiers

Do let baby adjust to feeding schedule before introducing pacifier in a breastfed baby.

Do choose one piece, easy to clean pacifiers for easy cleaning.

Do keep it clean.

Do replace often.

Don’t use the pacifier as the only means of comfort. Try other solutions first.

Don’t add sugar or juice to the pacifier.

Don’t force baby to use he pacifier if they do not want to.

Here are some tips to help your child stop using a pacifier:

There are some disagreements between doctors as to the age a pacifier is no longer good to use. Some doctors recommend the baby is weaned off at 1 year, and some are ok to wait until the child is 3 or 4 and can self wean off the pacifier.

There is a great 3 day plan created by Mark L. Brenner which you can use to wean your baby off the pacifier.

Day 1: The first day is all about mentally preparing your child to no longer be using the pacifier.

Day 2: Let your child know that in 2 days time there will no longer be a pacifier.

Day 3: This is the day you will team up with your child and look for all the pacifiers in the home and put them in a bag. You will say goodbye to the pacifiers and assure your little on that they no longer need them.

Non-Toxic Baby Pacifiers

The information here is for educational purposes only. Baby Gadget List does not accept any responsibility for any liability, loss or risk, personal or otherwise from any information contained here. Baby Gadget List may earn a commission from affiliate links in this content. Learn more about how this content is written here.

You may also like...