The Best Soy Formula
Because it is dairy-free, soy can be a lifesaver for newborns who require a non-milk-based formula. It’s also a wonderful choice for families that adhere to strict dietary restrictions, such as vegetarian or kosher diets. Furthermore, because it is easy to digest, soy is a mild, plant-based alternative that may be the ideal option for sensitive stomachs. Many newborns have fussiness and gas, which can be alleviated by using a soy formula. Earth’s Finest Non-GMO Plant Based Infant Formula is the best soy formula on the market.
(This post contains affiliate links. Our full disclosure policy is really boring, but you can find it here.)
Best Soy Formula for Your Baby
Earth’s Best Plant-Based Powder Formula with Iron
The only non-GMO soy formula on our list is Earth’s Best Plant-Based Powder Formula with Iron. It’s also the only soy alternative on the market that’s organic. It has an automatic advantage over other soy formulas because the brand strives to utilize the best components.
It isn’t perfect, though, because it has two components that we want to avoid in infant formula: corn syrup and palm oil. While they are ubiquitous in any formula, it would be good to come up with a fresh carbohydrate option.
That said, we adore Earth’s Best since they only utilize the best ingredients, organic and non-GMO, which sets them apart from the competition.
The components are laid out similarly to breastmilk, with carbs first, protein second, lipids third, and then all of the other nutrients. As previously stated, the major source of nourishment is maize syrup solids.
Then there’s the soy protein, which isn’t an isolate. Isolate is a technique that removes all of the other nutrients from the soybean. At the very least, your kid will obtain all of the nutrients found in soybeans if you choose this choice. This may make it more difficult for certain kids to break down this choice, but it does provide a bit more health.
Organic palm oil, soy oil, coconut oil, and safflower or sunflower oil are among the fats in this recipe.
Organic palm oil, soy oil, coconut oil, and safflower or sunflower oil are among the fats in this recipe. Palm oil is also a source of worry since it can cause tougher stools and limit calcium absorption. Hopefully, Earth’s Best will reduce or eliminate palm oil from their formulations in the near future.
Following that, the recipe includes ARA and DHA for brain health. After that, you’ll be given a long list of vitamins and minerals to keep your baby healthy. The recipe does, however, include one extra soy component, organic soy lecithin, which is a source of omega 3 and 6 fatty acids. Soy lecithin has several advantages, however, it may be extracted with hexane, which is contentious.
Earth’s Best recently updated their plant-based formula to use non-GMO soy rather than organic soy, but the rest of the components are still organic. The firm demonstrates a dedication to delivering the greatest ingredients for newborns. They also have a brain and immune support, with no milk to create problems.
While the formula still contains corny syrup, all businesses that produce soy formula do so since the FDA allows it. In any case, it’s our preferred option, albeit it’s not appropriate for every infant.
Many newborns may have hard feces and frequent spit-up, as well as dislike the flavour of soy formula, although this may happen with any soy formula.
Enfamil ProSobee Infant Formula
Enfamil ProSobee Infant Formula is one of the most popular soy formulas from a well-known infant formula manufacturer. Corn syrup solids are the major carbohydrate in this formula, as they are in all soy formulas. Worse, the major sources of fat in the mix are palm and soy oils. The formula, on the other hand, aids in brain growth.
We’d want to see Enfamil incorporate some of their designer components, such as Lactoferrin or MFGM, into their soy formula. Babies with sensitive stomachs, on the other hand, may require a plant-based formula.
Let’s look at the components to understand what makes this powder so special.
You’d assume that the first component in a soy formula would be soy, but unfortunately, carbs and lipids come before the soy protein isolate. Carbohydrates come first in breastmilk, followed by protein, lipids, vitamins, and minerals.
This one, like other soy formulas, begins with 54 percent corn syrup. That implies your kid is getting glucose instead of lactose, which is found in breastmilk and cow’s milk.
The recipe also includes a 26 percent vegetable oil blend that includes palm olein, coconut, soy, and high oleic sunflower oil. Palm oil, as previously stated, can lower the amount of calcium absorbed by infants.
Not to mention that your kid already consumes soy in the form of protein and does not require it in the form of fats.
After that, there’s 14 percent soy protein isolate as the major component. Keep in mind that soy protein isolate is controversial since it might mimic the actions of oestrogen (hormone) in the body, which could be harmful to babies.
The ARA and DHA, which are beneficial fats used to promote brain, eye, and immune health, are the next group of components. The remaining components are vitamins and minerals that infants require to remain healthy.
You should certainly pick Enfamil ProSobee if your kid has a milk allergy or intolerance and soy is the best alternative. However, we wish the formula had less corn syrup and a more comprehensive list of fats. It does not, however, add sugar to the formula in addition to the corn syrup, which is a significant advantage because newborns do not require more sugar.
We’d like to see more creative ingredients as well, but because soy is generally reserved for kids with milk allergies, most firms avoid using it due to a lack of demand. Furthermore, many of these designer components may contain cow milk, defeating the aim of being plant-based.
Similac Soy Isomil
Check out the Similac Soy Isomil if you’re searching for a soy-based formula with less corn syrup. While there is still corn syrup in it, it isn’t as much, and the recipe is at least a little closer to the right sequence, with carbs coming first, followed by proteins, and finally fats. Furthermore, Similac’s OptiGro, which is their own term for DHA, lutein, and vitamin E, is included in the formula.
The product is advertised as being vegetarian-friendly and calming for sensitive stomachs. It’s a mild formula for newborns suffering from lactose intolerance or galactosemia (a disorder that affects how the body processes the sugar galactose).
Corn syrup solids are the initial component, however, they account for just 40% of the total. This is a superior ratio since it allows the other components to have a greater impact on your baby’s health. Next, as soy formula, you’ll discover 15 percent soy protein isolate, which is similar to breastmilk in terms of how carbohydrates, protein, and fat fill out the liquid.
The fats come next, and Similac Isomil uses safflower, soy, and coconut oil instead of the problematic palm oil. While we don’t like for soy as a whole, it’s difficult to disagree with the results. When feasible, we’d want to see a reduction in superfluous components.
The catch is that the recipe includes 10% sugar mixed in with the oils. Corn syrup solids, a kind of sugar, is present in the initial component, and then more sugar is added. The powder has now accumulated a full 50% fat content.
The inclusion of prebiotic fructooligosaccharides to Similac’s Isomil is one of its advantages (or FOS for short). This ingredient is a sweetener, but it’s a good one since it’s high in soluble fibre, feeds probiotics, and can help lower blood sugar.
Yes, corn syrup is a safe energy source, but safe does not always imply healthily. Following that, DHA and ARA are included in the components for brain and immune wellness. Finally, there are vitamins and minerals, which are all of high quality.
While vitamins and minerals are vital, the formula’s major components take precedence. Although Similac Isomil has less sugar than Enfamil’s ProSobee, it still contains a significant amount of sugar for a formula that will be your baby’s sole source of nutrition for the first few months of his or her life.
Also, despite its vegetarian marketing, this formula does not specify non-GMO on the label, despite the fact that it contains two main GMO sources: sugar and maize. It does not, however, include the problematic palm oil, and we wish it had gone further in avoiding controversial components.
Mama Bear Powder Infant Formula with Iron
Mama Bear Powder Infant Formula with Iron is a soy formula that doesn’t cost as much as a branded brand. Mama Bear is a brand created by Amazon to compete with Similac Soy Isomil and Enfamil ProSobee. It has a similar nutritional profile as Isomil, but without the additional sugar.
The firm claims that as a lactose-free formula, it would provide full nourishment while reducing gas and fussiness. In addition, the firm includes other substances that are intended to promote the health of newborns. Corn syrup is presumably the first component, but that’s a given with soy infant formula.
Let’s take a deeper look at the formula.
This soy formula follows the same structure as breastfeeding, with carbs, protein, fat, prebiotic, and finally all of the vitamins and minerals. The first component is corn syrup, followed by soy protein isolate. Palm olein, soy oil, coconut oil, and either safflower or sunflower oil are used as fats in the recipe.
Again, palm oil and soy oil are divisive at best, and it would be ideal if all formula manufacturers avoided using them. Following that, DHA, ARA, and lutein are added for eye and immune development. Prebiotic fructooligosaccharide is added to assist enhance gut health.
The formula contains all of the vitamins and minerals that a newborn needs.
Mama Bear soy formula has the same high fat content as Similac and similar amounts of everything, but it doesn’t include the sugars that Similac has. One of the things we like about this recipe is that it has superior ingredients and is less expensive than the two most popular name-brand alternatives. It is not, however, non-GMO or organic, thus the quality of the components is unknown.
This is a great alternative for people on a budget because it contains less sugar and provides adequate nourishment for newborns. It is not without flaws, though, because it contains palm oil.
Comparison of Soy Formulas
Only the suggested goods on this page are compared in the table below. A low or high price indicates that it is low or costly in comparison to the other items on the list. The Popularity Score indicates how frequently readers click on the product and purchase it. The Quality Score is our evaluation of the product’s overall performance and satisfaction in comparison to the other products in the table.
When Should You Use Soy Formula?
Babies with a milk allergy or intolerance may require soy or plant-based formula instead. Soy may also be the best option for newborns who are lactose intolerant or suffer from congenital galactosemia.
Furthermore, many parents want to eat a vegan, vegetarian, or kosher diet, limiting their formula choices.
If your infant is just gassy and cranky, soy formula may not be necessary.
Remember that milk contains two proteins: whey and casein. Whey is less likely than casein to cause an allergic reaction. Because they are for young calves, the proteins in cows are bigger. The proteins in breastmilk are easier to digest since they are designed for humans.
Another distinction is that cow milk has 20% whey and 80% casein, whereas breastfeeding contains 60% whey and just 40% casein. If your baby is irritable or gassy, it’s possible that they don’t have a milk allergy, but they don’t respond well to a formula that has more casein than whey.
Try formulas with more whey and less casein, or formulas with hydrolyzed proteins (proteins that have been broken down into more digestible bits to aid digestion in infants).
Because soy is such a divisive topic, we strongly advise speaking with your doctor or a dietitian before switching to soy formula. You have alternatives before converting to soy because there are so many different formula options.
Milk Allergy Symptoms in Infants
Look for the following signs before switching to soy:
- Skin rash with dry, flaky areas
- Hives or blotchy red patches
- Diaper rash remedies do not eliminate a red ring around the anus.
- Swollen lips or a swollen mouth
- Passing gas is difficult.
- After eating formula, I became quite cranky and irritated.
Soy Formula Alternative
For gassy and cranky infants, soy isn’t the sole option. Try mild infant formulas with hydrolyzed protein and extra whey before introducing soy. Consider delicate or comfort formulas, as well as formulas containing A2 Milk, which is considered to be more easily digestible.
Most major formula makers, such as Enfamil’s Nutramigen or Similac Pro-Sensitive, have alternatives for newborns who are allergic to cow milk.
Else Plant-Based Baby Formula is another totally plant-based alternative. It’s non-GMO, organic, dairy-free, soy-free, and even corn-free. It does, however, include almond butter, which is a frequent allergy, as well as maltodextrin (corn-based).
Pure amino acid infant formulae are also available, although they contain corn syrup.
Before converting to soy, consider Enfamil Enspire or Reguline, which include more whey or partially hydrolyzed proteins for easier digestion.
To be sure, every infant formula has at least one unfavorable component. Determine which components are most important to you, and carefully read the label of any formula you’re considering for your baby before purchasing it. In the end, the greatest decision is the formula that your baby can and will drink, as all are FDA-approved for safety.
Problems With Soy Formula
Most soy formula choices contain GMOs, which is one of the primary concerns. Corn and soy are the two major components, and both are among the most widely used GMOs. Also, not just the soy protein, but also the soy oil, which are both included in the soy-based formula, has been linked to health problems. They should only be used as a last option for newborns since they can create long-term hormone problems.
A large amount of corn syrup and other sweets used as carbs instead of lactose is the second major concern with soy formula. While lactose is a sweet carbohydrate similar to corn syrup, it has a distinct molecular structure that is better for babies.
Finally, there is no evidence that soy formula helps with colic or allergies. Most soy formulas are intended to be for gassy and fussy newborns, not for babies who are allergic to milk or have an allergy to it. Soy should never be the first choice, but businesses are labeling formulas incorrectly instead of explicitly indicating that it should only be used as a last resort if milk-based choices are not suitable for your kid.
Soy Formula Frequently Asked Questions
The Best Soy Formula Bottom Line
For irritable and gassy newborns or those who can’t receive milk-based formula owing to the contentious components, soy formula should be a last choice. Because soy and corn make up the great majority of soy formulae, getting the best corn and soy is important. Let’s take a look at some of the best soy formulations available. Then determine whether soy is appropriate for your child and consider alternate choices.
If you must use a soy formula, go for Earth’s Best Plant-Based Soy Formula, which has non-GMO and organic components. Although it contains corn syrup and palm oil, it has higher-quality ingredients that are better for infants.